Being a psychology minor / philosophy enthusiast /nerd, I’ve heard the arguments and theories from both teams nature and nurture. For those playing at home, the nature vs. nurture debate is about where personality, intelligence and behaviors stem from – either from your DNA, genes, heritage etc (nature) or from your personal experiences (nurture). I’ve always been on the fence on the issue, but I lean more toward the nurture argument. Probably because as far as epistemology is concerned, I always liked the tabula rasa theory (Aristotle?). Anyway, I always thought we’re all a product of our experiences and that we aren’t limited or confined upon birth to being a certain way. Maybe that’s just wishful thinking but I believe it none the less.
I wrote a thesis paper last semester where I had to come up with my own personal theory on where I think personality stems from so I won’t go too in depth into this, but if you really want to read it I’ve uploaded it – link at the bottom of this page. It’s a pretty easy read if you’re into this sort of thing.
A few weeks ago I went out for lunch with my family, and my brother was asking Mum all the questions about our Opa because he passed away when we were very young. I was seven and he was nine, so we didn’t really get to know him. Mum and Dad were giving him alot of pretty superficial responses like “He was a very good man” and “he was happy, kind of stern but very happy”. This wasn’t enough for my brother so he kept prodding until he got some more concrete examples, and something suddenly occured to my mother. “Mindy is alot like him actually, alot, alot like him”. She listed all these things that he would do, specific instances of him displaying certain behaviors and characteristics that I do and have as well. The similiaries we have run the gamut from the bigger personality traits like being very decisive and motivated (and judgemental, shhh) down the little things like going “hmmm”, “mmhmm” and “mmmm” (that last one is the “psychiatrists ‘mmmm’, not a ‘mmmm’ this is delicious ‘mmmm’) and thinking that these are somehow appropriate responses as opposed to using actual words. (I need to stop doing that, I know.)
So now I don’t know what to think. Like I said, I was only seven years old when my Opa passed away so it doesn’t really make any sense that I should be so much like him, and that all of these personality traits have really only come up in the last few years. So, I’m back on the fence.
What do you think about the whole thing? I’m being serious, i want to know what everyone thinks on the issue – where do you fall on the debate and why? Comment or e-mail me.
Here’s a link, on the off chance you’re interested in learning more about this without getting too technical. Nature Vs. Nurture – How Hereditary and Environment Shape Who We Are
On a completely unrelated note, this Saturday evening Vh1 is playing No Direction Home, the Martin Scorcese documentary about Bob Dylan. I’m a big Bob Dylan fan and I actually own this DVD, but I must say this; If, you are not already a Bob Dylan fan, don’t watch it. You’ll hate it. It’s very long and quite frankly, it can be tedious. If you are a Bob Dylan fan and would like to get to know more about his life and where he’s coming from, definitely watch it – you’ll love it and it’s a great introduction to the finer points of his early career.
I hope everyone had a good thanksgiving, and thank you to everyone who messaged me / texted me / emailed me or whatever to make fun of me being a non-celebrating foreigner.
mindy munizaga – cognitive social modeling theory
it happens.
Published Wednesday, November 14, 2007 Movies , Music , Personal , Thoughts , social commentary 7 CommentsTags: mix CD's, Music, Personal, Thoughts
Imagine coming home from a long day of work, you take off your jacket because it’s bloody freezing out. You collapse on the couch and say to someone, “I had the worst day…” As the wheels in your head are a-spinnin, thinking about how you can explain the horror of your day to somebody who’ll listen to and appease you, they say “eh, it happens.”
It’s pretty rude. It makes the complainers’ complaints seem invalid and groundless, and all they wanted to do was vent for a little while. And i’m not talking about the “oh I stubbed my toe” complaint – because that really does just happen, but I mean the legitimately bad days. I only mention this because I know someone who says this all the time and a few days ago, I really wanted to complain to them but I reconsidered based on this. Despite what you may think, i’m not much of a complainer (yes, i know that right now i’m complaining about being unable to complain…) but I just like to think that if I were going to complain, you’d listen.
On a completely unrelated note, I want to talk about mix CD’s for a while. I like to think that most people in the world have seen the movie High Fidelity (if you havn’t seen it, watch it. Or better yet, read the book by Nick Hornby of which the film is based, then watch it). In the movie, there’s a great quote.
“The making of a great compilation tape, like breaking up, is hard to do and takes ages longer than it might seem. You gotta kick off with a killer, to grab attention. Then you got to take it up a notch, but you don’t wanna blow your wad, so then you got to cool it off a notch. There are a lot of rules.”
I make alot of mix CD’s and playlists. As anyone who’s been in my car knows, that’s usually what i’ll listen to when I’m driving, and i’ll listen to albums at home or work (currently listening to Abbey Road for instance). I like to think I make good mixes, and i’ve been told that I do; however, I don’t have a strategy when making one. I mean there are some obvious rules. I don’t put a song by Bright Eyes on and then listen to Journey (although, that would be interesting). I try to stay in the same genre, and try to avoid having too many songs by the same artist on the one mix. Unless of course, i’m making a mix of an artist to expose listeners to brilliance (Hi Jenn! Elliott Smith!).
So tell me, Internet – Do you have any rules to play by when you’re making a mix CD? I’ve found some advice and how-to lists but I feel like they’re either very serious or very stupid, it’s not working for me.